the meatball shop
Thursday, September 2nd, 2010Only in New York (well maybe a few other places) can a restaurant open, specialize in one food, and really perfect it. Everyone has seen the cupcake shops, dumpling houses, and whatnot…but a place specializing in meatballs is something that I wasn’t expecting.
That is not to say the meatball can’t be perfected, or that there can’t be many varieties…and that is exactly what the Meatball Shop brings to the table.
The Meatball Shop offers five types of meatballs. Classic Beef, Spicy Pork, Chicken, Vegetable, and a Weekly Special. You pick your meatballs, your sauce (Tomato, Meat, Mushroom, or Parmesan Cream), and then have to choose if you will have them on a sandwich (white or wheat) or in a bowl over a bed of something delicious. The menus are all dry erase, and you check what you want and give it to your server. Check out the menu here.
Anoop took me the Meatball Shop back on my birthday, and I’ve been dreaming of going back ever since.
I ordered Spicy Pork Meatballs w/classic tomato sauce, provolone cheese, on a whole wheat bread (sliders are also available, and they look adorable). The sandwich was exactly what you would expect. The meatballs were tender, cooked perfectly, and the combination I chose was just what I wanted. Exactly what I expect when I order a classic meatball sandwich (something that I grew up eating). I would be interested in trying the same combination with the beef meatballs, especially since I was inspired recently to take a stab at making my own. There were so many combination that I don’t think eating meatballs could ever get old.
On top of it being a top notch sandwich you get an amazing side salad too! At many restaurants the side salad is an after thought, but at the Meatball Shop I got delicious greens topped with Italian cheese, and a light but wonderful dressing. This place gets points for presentation too. It’s a $9 sandwich and salad, but it’s a lot of food…you won’t leave feeling hungry.
The Meatball Shop is a place you can bring just about anyone. I mean it has vegetarian options, and it can satisfy even my picky family. It’s comfort food, it’s Italian, and it’s unique. Definitely worth a try, and after you go you will probably deem it worthy of at least a second or third visit (I’m really into the idea of the meatball sandwich as comfort food).
Not only did this lunch prove to provide me with one sandwich…but actually two:
There is a much smaller desert menu, but it features a desert sandwich not to be missed…the ice cream sandwich. This desert menu is set up the same way…pick your ice cream…pick your cookie. We got Espresso ice cream smashed between chocolate chip cookies. Perfect size for two people to share, and completely delicious. A great way to end an already perfect lunch.
———————————————
The meatball sandwich and salad run $9, and the ice cream sandwich was $4. Both well worth it.
The Meatball Shop is located
84 Stanton St
(between Allen St & Orchard St)
on the Lower East Side
New York, NY
——————————-
- this post is part of This Week In Sandwiches
- all my food posts can be found here.

















